The Carpenter, Babel, and Carry Me Back.

This year, what are most likely my three favourite folk bands each released a new album, two of which have been added to my favourite albums of all time.


Carry Me Back
by Old Crow Medicine Show

Carry Me Back is Old Crow's fourth full length album, and their first in four years, since the release of Tennessee Pusher.

I was introduced to their music with O.C.M.S. only a few years ago, and the raw, unrefined bluegrass energy and excitement, and the pride in their own heritage and the heritage of our nation made me fall in love. The love continued with the palpable passion of Big Iron World, and they became one of my favourite artists in any genre. Sadly, when I bought Tennessee Pusher, I was disappointed that the energy seemed to have dissipated; the music was played with skill, and the songs were well composed, but the passion was missing, and with some refinement the exuberance faded – that's not to say that the music became melancholy; their first albums were brilliantly balanced between joy and sorrow.
Carry Me Back has the most refined sound of all of their releases, and yet, the palpable passion, the obvious joy and enjoyment of their craft, the intimacy, and the raw bluegrass are as present as at the first. Carry Me Back is a wonderful example of the perfect melding of old-fashion art, and modern process.
I want to learn the banjo.


Babel
by Mumford & Sons

Babel is a good record, but it's not great.

Sigh No More was an extremely powerful record in so many ways: the music was raw and untamed, imaginative, vibrant; the lyrics were beautifully written, and hard hitting and relatable; it was perfectly constructed, each song having its own flavour, yet being cohesive and united – it was an instant classic, received by a massive audience, many of whom didn't know they had any like for folk music.

So what happened?

I know, most of you are about to close this page and grumble about some stupid hipster who only likes obscure music at the expense of quality – but hear me out.
Sigh No More was untamed and passionate, but Babel feels restrained. The lyrics are still beautiful, still relatable, and the music is still played skillfully, but there's something missing; it feels like they were trying to duplicate the success of their first album – something they could easily have done, had they only filled a disc with incoherent noise – which they did, simply because of the fan-base built with Sigh No More. The title-track, "Babel," is a powerful introduction, and the lead single, "I Will Wait" was a good choice as such, and "Lovers Eyes" begins with beautiful, subdued harmony, but fades into almost the same chord progression as the first half of the album.
All that being said, "Lover of the Light," "Hopeless Wanderer," "Broken Crown," and "Not With Haste" are brilliant tracks, demonstrating the same passion and imagination shown in their first album, and their rendition of Simon and Garfunkel's "The Boxer" is a captivating cover (the not near as much so as the original).
I'm sure that I will gradually fall in love with this album, as I have with others, but my first impressions are that it is restrained music attempting to convey unrestrained joy and sorrow.
Please don't hate me.


The Carpenter
By The Avett Brothers

The Avett Brothers' I and Love and You was a huge hit, but it was not an instant classic for me, as Emotionalism, Mignonette, and the Gleam EP & Second Gleam were; in fact, it took me more than two years for me to fall in love with it. There were select tracks that I actually disliked for a long time ("Kick Drum Heart,""Tin Man," "Slight Figure of Speech," and "It Goes On and On"). But The Carpenter... now that's an entirely different story.

There is not a song, not a verse, not a lyric, not a note on this record I do not love. They have managed to perfectly combine the magic of Emotionalism with the mainstream refinement of I and Love and You without sacrificing any of the passion of their earlier music. "The Once and Future Carpenter" is a perfect opener, and "Live and Die" follows it perfectly. "Through My Prayers" literally makes my eyes well-up with tears (but that's because I have a personal connection with the lyrics). I honestly do not think The Avett Brothers have written a better, more cohesive, or more beautiful album.
The Carpenter is absolute perfection.
Forgive my gushing fanboy nature.